Inside China’s On-line Fentanyl Chemical Networks Serving to Gasoline The Opioid Disaster : NPR


In May 2019, China's government banned the production and sale of fentanyl and its many variants. But more than a year later, Chinese vendors continue to market the precursors used to make fentanyl online and ship them directly to customers in the United States, Europe and Mexico.

In May 2019, China's government banned the production and sale of fentanyl and its many variants. But more than a year later, Chinese vendors continue to market the precursors used to make fentanyl online and ship them directly to customers in the United States, Europe and Mexico.

He’s a slight, bespectacled man. Colleagues on the industrial supplies firm the place he works describe him as a humorous however diligent worker, recognized for driving his white Jeep round city in northwestern China’s Ningxia area to fulfill potential purchasers.

Unbeknownst to them, he goes Benjamin Chen on-line, the place he has a complete different enterprise: He is a well-liked vendor of the chemical substances used to make the potent artificial opioid fentanyl. NPR has recognized him however shouldn’t be utilizing his actual title due to the criminality through which he is concerned.

Chen is one in all greater than 100 distributors who market fentanyl or associated chemical substances out of amenities throughout China, and his story illustrates how networks are getting round worldwide efforts to crack down on the availability chain of deadly artificial opioids. In an interview with NPR, nonetheless, Chen categorically denied that he manufactures or sells any unlawful substances.

For years, China has been a main supply of fentanyl trafficked into the US. It’s a highly effective prescription drug for extreme ache that is made and offered illegally. It led to greater than 37,000 overdose deaths within the U.S. in 2019, a part of a nationwide opioid disaster that has worsened this yr in the course of the coronavirus pandemic, in line with federal well being authorities.

Beneath worldwide stress, China’s authorities banned the manufacturing and sale of fentanyl and plenty of of its variants in Might 2019, leading to a big discount within the nation’s illicit fentanyl commerce.

However greater than a yr later, Chinese language distributors have tapped into on-line networks to overtly market fentanyl analogs and the precursor chemical substances used to make fentanyl, and ship them on to clients within the U.S. and Europe in addition to to Mexican cartels, in line with an NPR investigation and analysis from the Heart for Superior Protection Research, or C4ADS, a nonprofit information evaluation group. (The middle receives a few of its funds from the U.S. and U.Ok. governments.)

A number of the substances are outlawed in China and internationally. Others are so new they aren’t but banned, are more durable to detect and regulate, they usually can be utilized in primary chemical processes to supply unlawful medicine.

Chinese language distributors are sometimes camouflaged a fancy community of company entities registered in far-flung cities alongside China’s inside, the place they use subtle transport strategies to pass screening measures and the place regulation enforcement scrutiny is usually laxer than in greater cities reminiscent of Beijing or Shanghai. Hundreds of doses will be shipped collectively in small, hidden packages.

“Many Chinese language networks concerned within the manufacturing and promoting of fentanyl shortly tailored to elevated authorized constraints modifying their methods to take advantage of loopholes in chemical restrictions and disguise their actions,” mentioned Michael Lohmuller, a C4ADS analyst and report co-author.

Arduous to ban

When China started banning fentanyl-related compounds, it was hailed as a serious victory for U.S. narcotics authorities and diplomats, who had lobbied China for years to strictly regulate the substances extra broadly as a category. Beforehand, Chinese language narcotics authorities criminalized solely particular fentanyl offshoots.

Sacks of coal products await sale at a producing web site in northwestern China’s Ningxia area, the place Benjamin Chen works as a salesman.

Emily Feng/NPR


conceal caption

toggle caption

Emily Feng/NPR

Sacks of coal products await sale at a producing web site in northwestern China’s Ningxia area, the place Benjamin Chen works as a salesman.

Emily Feng/NPR

Months after China’s class ban final yr, as tensions escalated between the Trump administration and the federal government beneath China’s chief Xi Jinping, Chinese language-made fentanyl compounds as soon as once more turned a divisive subject.

“President Xi mentioned this might cease — it did not,” President Trump tweeted in August 2019.

China’s authorities refutes this, saying its ban and crackdown on Web promoting, gross sales and shipments have been efficient.

“At the moment, there’s principally no data associated to the unlawful gross sales of fentanyl-class chemical substances on web sites inside Chinese language borders or pharmaceutical and chemical platforms,” China’s Nationwide Narcotics Management Fee mentioned in a press release to NPR. “However as a result of openness, anonymity, comfort, cross-border nature of the Web, any nation would have a tough time utterly eradicating unlawful data.”

The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration notes that the detected quantity of Chinese language fentanyl shipments has dropped dramatically because the ban.

“It was all coming means of the mail, plane, not in giant portions as a result of it was so pure the fentanyl that they have been making over in China … however as soon as they labeled complete analogs of fentanyl, it made an enormous distinction,” mentioned Matt Donahue, the DEA deputy chief of operations who oversees the company’s work overseas.

Distributors create new distribution technique

Regardless of the drop in fentanyl shipments from China, nimble Chinese language distributors have developed new distribution methods producing and promoting the precursor chemical substances used to make fentanyl.

Benjamin Chen is among the many many distributors within the nation who adopted these new methods. He and his colleagues constructed up a sturdy on-line artificial drug operation during the last decade at Shanghai Huilitongda Organic Expertise Co. Ltd., which is registered as a pharmaceutical firm, in line with Chinese language company data.

On Fb, the place he did a lot of his promoting, Chen had a repute as a quick and dependable vendor, in line with social media opinions left almost a dozen clients. “Benjamin Chen is the actual deal,” somebody recognized as a buyer wrote in a Fb submit in December 2018. “If he cannot do it, no one can.”

Potential purchasers may examine grainy snapshots of nondescript powders and capsules on Fb. Often, Chen replied on to loyal clients, even paying for a Lyft journey to the hospital as compensation when one buyer complained he had overdosed on Chen’s product.

Generally working beneath the pseudonym “King Solar” or “Solar King,” he additionally marketed his chemical wares brazenly on LinkedIn, Twitter and Vimeo earlier than and after the category ban final yr.

Chen tailored to the ban promoting fentanyl precursors, or what he referred to as “scorching merchandise for analysis chemical substances” — compounds which are only some chemical steps away from a fentanyl analog and that aren’t at all times criminalized. Different substances on sale included a typically lethal artificial opioid also called “pink,” and artificial cannabinoids.

Chen adapted to the ban  selling fentanyl precursors, or what he called "hot products for research chemicals" — compounds that are only a few chemical steps away from a fentanyl analog and are not always criminalized.

Chen adapted to the ban  selling fentanyl precursors, or what he called "hot products for research chemicals" — compounds that are only a few chemical steps away from a fentanyl analog and are not always criminalized.

C4ADS discovered at the very least 31 distributors on Alibaba, the Chinese language wholesale e-commerce platform, promoting 4 fentanyl precursors beneath shortened chemical serial numbers in September 2019, greater than three months after the fentanyl class ban went into impact. Alibaba has since taken down almost all listings for these 4 precursors.

Since April, nonetheless, C4ADS has recognized 32 distributors on Alibaba promoting two different precursors that can be utilized to make fentanyl however are usually not banned in both the U.S. or China.

In a press release to NPR, Alibaba mentioned that it “prohibits the itemizing third-party sellers of any managed substances” and that the corporate cooperates with regulation enforcement when wanted.

Whereas stricter regulation has not worn out the fentanyl-related trade in China, it has made it harder for illicit distributors to function.

A salesman for Hebei Aicrowe Biotech Co. Ltd., a prescribed drugs maker registered in Shijiazhuang, the capital of Hebei province, mentioned the corporate had drastically decreased the variety of artificial opioids and different compounds it provided due to the heightened authorized scrutiny in China.

However when NPR visited the corporate in November 2019, the salesperson confirmed it nonetheless offered “99918,” which is code for a preferred fentanyl precursor, in line with C4ADS analysts, and was banned in China in 2018.

“The client has the duty to ensure the compound is authorized the place the receiving deal with is,” the salesperson mentioned.

A lot of the chemical substances salespeople NPR spoke to for this story didn’t give their names. Their work may result in harsh punishment in China, the place drug trafficking is punishable loss of life.

Simple to make, simple to cover

Fentanyl manufacturing and exports proceed apace in obscure Chinese language cities. One laboratory in Hebei province was tucked inside a sprawling industrial warehouse advanced.

Inside, narcotics investigators discovered a prolific fentanyl manufacturing operation — all contained inside two small rooms with “product drying on tape in sheet cake pans,” mentioned a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement official posted in China. The official spoke on situation of anonymity as a result of he was not approved to talk publicly to a reporter about his work on the case.

In November 2018, Chinese language police — appearing on a tip from the U.S. — seized greater than 26 kilos of fentanyl and 42 kilos of different medicine from the lab and ultimately sentenced 9 individuals from the town of Xingtai in Hebei a yr later in a serious Chinese language-U.S. joint drug takedown. The Xingtai authorities declined to be interviewed.

Fentanyl drug traffickers are sentenced in court docket final yr in Xingtai in northeast China’s Hebei province. The court docket sentenced at the very least 9 fentanyl traffickers in a case that was the fruits of a uncommon collaboration between Chinese language and U.S. regulation enforcement to crack down on world networks that manufacture and distribute deadly artificial opioids.

Jin Liangkuai/Xinhua through AP


conceal caption

toggle caption

Jin Liangkuai/Xinhua through AP

Fentanyl drug traffickers are sentenced in court docket final yr in Xingtai in northeast China’s Hebei province. The court docket sentenced at the very least 9 fentanyl traffickers in a case that was the fruits of a uncommon collaboration between Chinese language and U.S. regulation enforcement to crack down on world networks that manufacture and distribute deadly artificial opioids.

Jin Liangkuai/Xinhua through AP

The profitable bust gained worldwide reward but in addition drew consideration to how simply artificial opioids will be manufactured in small, clandestine areas with rudimentary gear.

“With globalization and provide chain administration run Internet-savvy criminals, you do not have to have this large, scary prison community,” mentioned the ICE official, who participated within the joint investigation. “You simply have to have the ability to run a enterprise and benefit from trendy expertise.”

Artificial opioid distributors favor figuring out of China’s industrial hinterlands, the place policing will be much less strict. Of the 92 fentanyl and fentanyl-analog promoting entities C4ADS was in a position to determine with location particulars, 41% listed their company deal with in Shijiazhuang. The provincial capital, in northeastern China, is thought for its once-thriving coal, metal and different heavy industries.

China has an enormous prescribed drugs and bulk chemical manufacturing sector, making compounds offered globally meant for authentic functions in medication and industrial processes. Artificial opioid distributors defend themselves behind layers of interlinked corporations registered in these sectors or associated fields reminiscent of biotechnology. The drug distributors NPR visited labored out of workplaces tucked away in purchasing malls, residential towers and industrial complexes.

“You are able to do this kind of enterprise from wherever,” mentioned a salesman at Crovell Biotech Co. Ltd., a fentanyl-analog vendor in Shijiazhuang. To maintain operations safe, Crovell staff mentioned they market and export their medicine in-house from Shijiazhuang, however the riskiest half — manufacturing the artificial compounds themselves — was executed Crovell staff “not close to right here.”

A producing web site the place Chen works as a salesman.

Emily Feng/NPR


conceal caption

toggle caption

Emily Feng/NPR

A producing web site the place Chen works as a salesman.

Emily Feng/NPR

Chen selected to function from a base in Ningxia, the place he labored at an organization promoting supplies utilized in steelmaking.

Company data seen C4ADS and NPR present Chen additionally registered a string of export and pharmaceutical corporations linked to his opioid-selling operation in Ningxia.

In September 2019, NPR managed to fulfill Chen on the industrial supplies firm the place he works. He wore sneakers and a black zip-up hoodie. When requested about his on-line accounts, Chen ushered the reporter into a personal convention room and shortly closed the door. His eyes darted round nervously, and he cleared his throat repeatedly

When confronted about his illicit enterprise, Chen advised NPR he didn’t promote fentanyl or precursors and denied he was the individual behind the moniker “King Solar.”

“I’ve no means executed something unlawful, and my work is all inside authorized bounds,” Chen mentioned.

Direct commerce

Entry to the Web provides even small-time sellers in China transnational attain to market and ship their potent merchandise.

Distributors proceed to function brazenly on platforms, together with Fb, Twitter, Wickr, MeWe and Vimeo, promoting a head-spinning array of chemical substances tagged with an obscure however internationally used numerical naming system.

“Sellers and consumers know the obscure acronyms, code names, chemical registration numbers and the like, and are in a position to change on a dime when one trusted member of a gaggle is raided or arrested,” mentioned Logan Pauley, a former C4ADS analyst who labored on the report.

Fb mentioned in a press release to NPR that its on-line requirements explicitly say “shopping for, promoting or buying and selling non-medical or pharmaceutical medicine shouldn’t be allowed on Fb. Any time we change into conscious of content material on Fb that’s facilitating exercise like drug gross sales, we take away it and have taken quite a few measures to attenuate the chance for these actions to happen on our platform.” (Fb is a monetary supporter of NPR.)

Synthetic opioid vendors have access to a powerful tool: the Internet, which gives even small-time sellers in China transnational reach in marketing and shipping their highly potent products.

Synthetic opioid vendors have access to a powerful tool: the Internet, which gives even small-time sellers in China transnational reach in marketing and shipping their highly potent products.

Twitter mentioned it doesn’t enable its platform for use to facilitate unlawful transactions and that its commercial coverage prohibits the promotion of medicine and paraphernalia.

The video platform Vimeo mentioned it “bans customers from importing or sharing content material on Vimeo that violates any relevant regulation,” together with fentanyl and fentanyl-related compounds.

The social media firm MeWe mentioned that “any group, web page, or member reported on MeWe that’s discovered to be promoting any kind of unlawful drug is swiftly eliminated MeWe’s Belief and Security Staff and could also be reported to the authorities.”

Wickr didn’t reply to requests for remark.

U.S. regulation enforcement acknowledged struggling to curb this on-line fentanyl market, partly as a result of most of the transactions are encrypted. “We all know it is taking place. We nonetheless can’t get cooperation from main Web corporations, service suppliers, to have the ability to get into these units that we all know [drug cartels] are using,” the DEA’s Donahue mentioned.

He pointed to the Chinese language social media platform WeChat as significantly problematic. WeChat’s dad or mum firm, Tencent, didn’t reply to NPR’s request for remark.

“Traffickers have intelligence identical to we do,” Donahue mentioned. “The Chinese language have nice intelligence. They know we won’t get into these things. That is why they make the most of these strategies of communication to have the ability to ship medicine. They know regulation enforcement would not have the means or the know-how or the sources to infiltrate.”

Medicine mail

In August 2019, greater than three months after China’s class ban, the U.S. authorities issued an advisory warning federal companies of continued shipments of fentanyl and different artificial opioids, together with through the U.S. Postal Service and personal specific mail providers. The Treasury Division has additionally used financial institution information to determine fentanyl distributors. In 2019, the division sanctioned three Chinese language nationals accused of trafficking the artificial opioids.

Nevertheless, distributors nonetheless handle to ship the packages inside aluminum alloy luggage means of worldwide mail carriers full with monitoring numbers, so clients can monitor the itinerary from midway around the globe.

“Our firm [is a legal business] in China. We provide [discreet] and dependable packaging and supply. Quick and dependable transport inside 48 hours, utilizing courier service, DHL, EMS, TNT, FedEx, UPS,” Gaosheng Biotechnology Co. Ltd. coached its gross sales associates to say on greater than 100 social media and promoting websites, in line with an organization doc seen NPR. The corporate has marketed an array of medicine, together with a preferred fentanyl analog referred to as furanyl fentanyl, in line with C4ADS.

Information from 2017 and 2018 present the quantity and absolute variety of U.S. seizures of fentanyl-related compounds shipped mail dropping drastically after U.S. Customs and Border Safety stepped up its screening of incoming worldwide packages.

However distributors in China mentioned they’ve managed to work across the further hurdles.

“We ship a particular approach, can guarantee you may obtain the products. Now we have the product in inventory,” a salesman for Hebei Speedgain Biotechnology Co. Ltd. mentioned through WhatsApp in Might. The corporate describes itself as a maker of drug and pesticide intermediates.

The salesperson mentioned the corporate additionally offered a banned fentanyl precursor, at $1,100 a kilogram.

A salesman at a distinct firm, Shunwei Organic, primarily based in Shijiazhuang, mentioned in Might that it was nonetheless promoting two fentanyl precursors and a spread of artificial cannabinoids to clients in the US. “We’re transport to the U.S. and have success with deliveries to your nation and others,” the salesperson mentioned.

One attainable approach across the screening is for distributors to ship giant volumes of illicit artificial opioids disguised inside lawful bulk cargo to the U.S., the place a distributor can then fulfill particular person American orders domestically. In 2017, the DEA arrested a Chinese language nationwide dwelling in Massachusetts and working such a warehouse of artificial opioids and different medicine obtained from China.

“It could possibly be that the mail shipments are down partly as a result of what has occurred is that the distributors have moved to transport it means of cargo to the US. … That information shouldn’t be being collected as a result of all of the seizures that I see are solely from [U.S.] ports of entry,” mentioned Bryce Pardo, who researches drug coverage at Rand Corp.

Drug provide chains are altering in different methods as traffickers have interaction in a cat-and-mouse sport to evade regulation enforcement.

This yr, the coronavirus pandemic briefly paralyzed the commerce. Many substances behind artificial opioids are made in Wuhan, the town the place the coronavirus was first found and which authorities utterly locked down for greater than two months.

“The cutoffs have been short-term,” mentioned Louise Shelley, a George Mason College professor who researches fentanyl provide chains and studied the impression of the pandemic on gross sales. “The issue has not ended. [Fentanyl sales] are nonetheless happening the open Internet.”

Within the U.S., in the meantime, greater than 40 states have reported spikes in opioid-related deaths this yr, in line with the American Medical Affiliation. Fentanyl, which is as much as 100 occasions stronger than morphine, is a number one reason for overdoses.

Mexican cartels have additionally begun distributing fentanyl merchandise, utilizing substances largely made in China. “Now the position of China — and the rising position of India — is sending precursor chemical substances on to cartels in Mexico to supply the fentanyl in clandestine labs,” the DEA’s Donahue mentioned. “You push on a balloon, it pops some place else.”

Extra Chinese language distributors are transferring to password-protected web sites, the place entry is given solely to trusted clients. They’re transferring away from public social media accounts, for safety causes and since many corporations, together with Instagram and Reddit, have carried out guidelines that make it more durable for illicit drug distributors to function. Chen’s Fb accounts have been shut down final yr, however he has created a brand new account.

Analysts mentioned a complete new class of artificial opioids — a household of compounds referred to as benzimidazoles — is now exhibiting up in U.S. drug busts and resulting in overdose deaths. The medicine are utterly completely different in chemical construction from fentanyl, however specialists warn they are often simply as lethal. Preliminary seizures of the medicine come from mailed packages originating in China, the place their manufacturing shouldn’t be managed.

“It is nonetheless a small quantity, however it’s alarming as a result of benzimidazoles could possibly be the type of new pathway illicit chemists have recognized, a brand new chemical construction that is not managed but and that is more durable to detect as a result of it is new,” mentioned Pardo of Rand Corp. “On the finish of the day, these chemists will determine new issues to get round these legal guidelines.”

NPR Beijing bureau producer Amy Cheng contributed analysis from Beijing. NPR dependancy correspondent Brian Mann contributed reporting from New York.





Supply hyperlink